Saturday, June 22, 2013

Putting the Public in Public Transportation

I recently contacted my cousin Paul for an interview about his experience riding the Northstar Commuter Train, because I knew it was not going to be a cut-and-dry informational interview about how the train works. When I first heard about the "Train Group" I thought my cousin was a part of a group of train enthusiasts, but after gaining more insight from other family members in the know, my interest grew as I learned he was actually part of a commuter social group. This kind of activity is not completely unheard of, in December the Star Tribune ran an article about a Northstar Commuter Train cookie exchange group, which was a lighthearted piece that covered the same subject matter, but there is something deeper that I hope to uncover in my own article.

Paul and his family are residents of Monticello, he has worked downtown Minneapolis for seven years and since starting that job has been a regular metro transit commuter. For four years Paul drove 30 miles to the park-and-ride in Maple Grove and then took the express bus into Minneapolis. Rising gas prices prompted Paul to begin looking for a different commute. His car gets about 30 miles to the gallon so during Paul’s round trip each day he was using two gallons of gas and ten gallons in a week which was more than he wanted. Paul had heard about the Northstar line and figured why not give it a try? The new route had him drive eight to nine miles to the Elk River station and catch the train. Paul’s employer covered $3 of the $5.50 fare, so he was spending $2.50 per trip and $5 a day which was definitely cheaper than two gallons of gas, he easily decided to make the switch.

As a commuter on the park and ride for four years, Paul never felt like he had made a connection with anyone who took the same bus that he did every day. Everyone seemed to keep to themselves, reading books, the newspaper, checking their phone, or working on their laptop. Even though they were all in the same vehicle, going to the same destination, and on the same schedule every day, they seemed to be in a realm of transition not interested in any social aspect or gaining any more acquaintances, just waiting to arrive at their destination. It didn't happen immediately, but the train turned out to be an entirely different experience for my cousin.

Paul had been riding the Northstar for a couple of months and finding it to be a similar experience to the bus, a kind of moving waiting room, but then one morning something unexpected happened. On the station platform he ran into a friend of his from high school who invited him to sit with her and some of her friends on the commute; that is when Paul finally found what he had been looking for. He joined the group that morning and now is full-time member.

They are a group of people who were interested in spending their commute in a social aspect that is outside their usual routine and gives them an opportunity to actually enjoy the commute. The current size of the entire group is about 20 people, but some have never met each other because everyone has different schedules. Based on what time you get on the train dictates who you end up sitting and chatting with during the commute. The usual and ideal size of the group per trip is eight because they can get eight seats together and easily be a part of the same conversation. If the group ends up larger they have been known to adjust and in many cases still a give hard time to others who are sitting in another part of the car.

As far as membership goes there is no initiation; it’s open to anyone who is looking for people to talk to. Paul says, "Anyone can join as long as they are willing to sit with us and put up with our antics." Besides riding the train together there are also social gatherings put together outside of the commute. These events give them more time to spend together and an opportunity to meet each other’s families. This helps put faces and personalities to names after everything they may have heard about these people prior to the event. Every year around Halloween they get together for a hayride and bonfire at Bunker Hills; throughout the year there are brunches at each other’s houses; and impromptu happy hours in either downtown Minneapolis or in Elk River. Recently the group enjoyed a boat trip that took the group from Hastings to Red Wing for an afternoon because a conductor on the train happens to own a large boat. Yes, you read that right conductors are even members of the group!


When Paul began taking the Northstar line it was a decision that was based on economics, but now it is the social aspect that is keeping him there. The reality of the situation is that people come and go from this group due to job transitions and other circumstances, but they have made lasting friendships and the idea of having this group as a permanent connection in their lives for the long run is something I am sure none of them ever expected the first time they got on the rails. For them the journey has always been the destination and the Northstar Line is a perfect fit.

As had mentioned above here is the link to the Star Tribune article about the Northstar cookie exchange:


Do you think this kind of social and interactive culture could be bred in any other from of public transportation or is it unique to the Northstar Commuter Train?

No comments:

Post a Comment